Does Relative Age Influence the Mechanisms That Foster Positive Youth Development Among Female Ice Hockey Players?
A Qualitative Examination
Keywords:positive youth development, relative age effect, female ice hockey, negative developmental experiences, qualitative research
The relative age effect (RAE) describes the physical and cognitive (dis)advantages experienced by athletes based upon when their birthdate falls relative to a pre-established cut-off date. Despite RAEs being present in a number of sports, few studies have explored how relative age influences the positive youth development (PYD) of athletes. This study examined the mechanisms that facilitate and hinder athletes’ acquisition of PYD outcomes and whether these are influenced by relative age. A secondary objective included determining how athletes employed these skills in other contexts. Twenty relatively older (n = 10) and younger (n = 10) competitive female ice hockey players were interviewed (Mage = 17. 2 years). Thematic analyses revealed that all athletes, regardless of their relative age, developed a range of PYD outcomes in the personal, physical, and social domains, and have applied these skills in a variety of contexts outside of sport. Across relative younger and older athletes, three interrelated themes emerged and served as the overarching mechanisms that facilitated or hindered athletes’ development of PYD outcomes: the social features of the sport environment, the structure of female travel/rep ice hockey, and negative ice hockey experiences. Our findings have implications for creating sport environments that foster PYD
Andronikos, G. Elumaro, A. I., Westbury, T., & Martindale, R. J. J. (2016). Relative age effect: Implications for effective practice. Journal of Sports Sciences, 34, 1124-1131.
Bailey, R., Cope, E. J., & Pearce, G. (2013). Why do children take part in, and remain involved in sport? International Journal of Coaching Science, 7(1), 56-75.
Baker, J., Schorer, J., & Cobley, S. (2010). Relative age effects: An inevitable consequence of elite sport? Sportwissenschaft, 40(1), 26-30. doi: 10.1007/s12662- 009-0095-2
Barnsley, R. H., Thompson, A. H., & Barnsley, P. E. (1985). Hockey success and birthdate: The RAE. Canadian Association for Health, Physical Education, and Recreation, 51, 23-28.
Barrow, H. M., & McGee, R. (1971). A practical approach to measurement in physical education. Philadelphia, PA: Lea & Febiger.
Bradshaw, C., Atkinson, S., Doody, O. (2017). Employing a qualitative description approach to health care research. Global Qualitative Nursing Research, 4, 1-8.
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77-101.
Chittle, L., Dixon, J. C., & Horton, S. (2019). Youth developmental experiences among female hockey players: The role of relative age. Journal of Youth Development, 14(4), 83-100. doi: 10.5195/jyd.2019.806
Chittle, L., Horton, S., & Dixon, J. C. (in press). Examining the role of relative age on leadership behaviors among female ice hockey players: An exploratory investigation. Journal of Amateur Sport.
Chittle, L., Horton, S., Weir, P., & Dixon, J. C. (2017a). Investigating the relationship between the relative age effect and leadership behaviors among male ice hockey players. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 52(6), 751-768. doi: 10.1177/1012690215616271
Chittle, L., Horton, S., Weir, P., & Dixon, J. C. (2017b). Exploring the relationship between relative age effect and youth development among male recreational ice hockey players. Journal of Amateur Sport, 3(1), 79-95.
Chittle, L., Horton, S., & Dixon, J. C. (2015). Exploring the relative age effect in Canadian interuniversity ice hockey. Talent Development & Excellence, 7(1), 69-81.
Cobley, S., Baker, J., Wattie, N., & McKenna, J. M. (2009a). Annual age-grouping and athlete development: A meta-analytic review of relative age effects in sport. Sports Medicine, 39(3), 235-256.
Côté, J., & Fraser-Thomas, J. (2011). Youth involvement and positive development in sport. In P.R.E. Crocker (ed.). Sport psychology: A Canadian perspective, (2nd ed., pp. 226-255). Toronto: Pearson Prentice Hall
Côté, J., Turnnidge, J., & Evans, M. B. (2014). The dynamic process of development through sport. Kinesiologia Slovenica, 20(3), 14-26.
Delorme, N., Boiché, J., & Raspaud, M. (2010). Relative age effect in female sport: A diachronic examination of soccer players. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 20, 509-515. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0838.2009.00979.x
Dhuey, E., & Lipscomb, S. (2008). What makes a leader? Relative age and high school leadership. Economics of Education Review, 27, 173-183.
Dworkin, J. B., Larson, R., & Hansen, D. (2003). Adolescents’ accounts of growth experiences in youth activities. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 32, 17-26.
Edwards, L., & O’Donoghue, P. G. (2014). Relative age effect in netball: A qualitative investigation. International Journal of Coaching Science, 8(1), 47-68.
Elliott, S., & Drummond, M. (2017). The experience of parent/coaches in youth sport: A qualitative exploration of junior Australian football. Special Issue: Family Issues in Amateur Athletics, 3(3), 64-85.
Fraser-Thomas, J., & Côté, J. (2009). Understanding adolescents’ positive and negative developmental experiences in sport. The Sport Psychologist, 23, 3-23.
Fraser-Thomas, J. L., Côté, J., & Deakin, J. (2005). Youth sport programs: An avenue to foster positive youth development. Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 10(1),19-40.
Fredricks, J. A., & Eccles, J. S. (2004). Parental influences on youth involvement in sports. In M. R. Weiss (Ed.), Developmental sport and exercise psychology: A lifespan perspective (pp. 145-164). Morgantown, WV: Fitness Information Technology
Fumarco, L., Gibbs, B. G., Javis, J. A., & Rossi, G. (2017). The relative age effect reversal among National Hockey League elite. PLoS ONE, 12(8), e0182827.
Geither, C. A., Molenaar, C. E., Henriksson, T., Fjellman-Wiklund, A., & Gilenstam, K. (2018). Relative age effects in women’s ice hockey: Contributions of body size and maturity status. Women in Sport and Physical Activity Journal, 26, 124-133.
Gibbs, B. G., Jarvis, J. A., & Durfur, M. J. (2011). The rise of the underdog? The relative age effect reversal among Canadian-born NHL hockey players: A reply to Nolan and Howell. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 47(5), 644-649.
Gould, D., & Carson, S. (2008). Life skills development through sport: Current status and future directions. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1, 58-78.
Hancock, D. (2017). Female relative age effects and the second-quartile phenomenon in young female ice hockey players. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 32, 12-16. DOI: 10.1016/j.psychsport.2017.05.002.
Hancock, D. J., Adler, A. L., & Côté, J. (2013) A proposed theoretical model to explain relative age effects in sport. European Journal of Sport Science, 13(6), 630-637.
Hancock, D. J., Seal, K., Young, B. W., Weir, P. L., & Ste-Marie, D. M. (2013). Examining mechanisms that contribute to relative age effects in pre-pubescent female ice hockey players. Talent Development & Excellence, 5, 59-66.
Hansen, D. M., & Larson, R. (2002). The youth experience survey 1.0: Instrument development and testing. Unpublished manuscript, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Retrieved from http://web.aces.uiuc.edu/youthdev/.
Hansen, D. M., & Larson, R. (2005). The youth experience survey 2.0: Instrument revisions and validity testing. Unpublished manuscript, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Retrieved from http://web.aces.uiuc.edu/youthdev/.
Helsen, W. F., Starkes, J. L., & Van Winckel, J. (1998). The influence of relative age on success and dropout in male soccer players. American Journal of Human Biology, 10, 791-798.
Hockey Canada. (2018). By-laws regulation history. Retrieved from https://cdn.hockeycanada.ca/hockey-canada/Corporate/About/Downloads/2018-19-bylaws-e.pdf
Holt, N. L., & Neely, K. C. (2011). Positive youth development through sport: A review. Revista de Iberoamericana de Psicología del Ejercicio y el Deporte (English version), 6, 299-316.
Holt, N. L., Neely, K. C., Slater, L. G., Camiré, M., Côté, J., Fraser-Thomas, J., MacDonald, D., Strachan, L., Tamminen, K. A. (2017). A grounded theory of positive youth development through sport based on results from a qualitative meta-study. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 10(1), 1-49. doi: 10.1080/1750984X.2016.1180704
Holt, N. L., Sehn, Z. L., Spence, J. C., Newton, A. S., & Ball, G. D. C., (2012). Physical education and sport programs at an inner city school: Exploring possibilities for positive youth development. Physical Education and Sport Pedagogy, 17(1), 97-113.
Jowett, S. (2008). Outgrowing the familial coach-athlete relationship. International Journal of Sport Psychology, 39(1), 20-40.
Jowett, S., Timson-Katchis, M., & Adams, R. (2007). Too close for comfort? International Journal of Coaching Science, 1(1), 59-78.
Larson, R. W., Hansen, D. M. & Moneta, G. (2006). Differing profiles of developmental experiences across types of organized youth activities. Developmental Psychology, 42(5), 849-863.
Lerner, R. M., Fisher, C. B., & Weinberg, R. A. (2000). Toward a science for and of the people: Promoting civil society through the application to developmental science. Child Development, 71(1), 11-20.
MacDonald, D.J., Côté, J., Eys, M. & Deakin, J. (2012) Psychometric properties of the Youth Experience Survey with young athletes. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 13, 332-340.
Maxwell, J.A. (1992). Understanding and validity in qualitative research. Harvard Educational Review, 62(3), 279-300.
McCarthy, N., & Collins, D. (2014). Initial identification & selection bias versus the eventual confirmation of talent: Evidence for the benefits of a rocky road? Journal of Sports Sciences, 32(17), 1604-1610.
Milne, J., & Oberle K. (2005). Enhancing rigor in qualitative description: A case study. Journal of Wound Ostomy & Continence Nursing, 32(6), 413-420.
Musch, J., & Grondin, S. (2001). Unequal competition as an impediment to personal development: A review of the relative age effect in sport. Developmental Review, 21, 147-167.
Neergaard, M., Olesen, F., Andersen, R., & Sondergaard, J. (2009). Qualitative description - The poor cousin of health research? BMC Medical Research Methodology, 9(52). Doi doi:10.1186/1471-2288-9-52
Neely, K. C., & Holt, N. L. (2014). Parents’ perspectives on the benefits of sport participation for young children. The Sport Psychologist, 28, 255-268.
Patton, M. Q. (2002). Qualitative evaluation and research methods (3rd ed.). Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Petitpas, A. J., Cornelius, A. E., Van Raalte, J. L., & Jones, T. (2005). A framework for planning youth sport programs that foster psychosocial development. The Sport Psychologist, 19(1), 63-80.
Roth, J. Brooks-Gunn, J., Murray, L., & W. Foster. (1998). Promoting healthy adolescents: Synthesis of youth development program evaluations. Journal of Research on Adolescence, 8, 423-459.
Sandelowski, M. (2000). Focus on research methods: Whatever happened to qualitative description. Research in Nursing & Health, 23, 334-340.
Sandelowski, M. (2010). What’s in a name? Qualitative description revisited. Research in Nursing & Health, 33(1), 77-84.
Sherman, A., & Hancock, D. J. (2016). Awareness and perceptions of relative age effects: A case study analysis. Journal of Sport & Exercise Psychology, 38. S255
Smith, K. L. (2019). The role of relative, community size, and positive youth development on female youth soccer participation. (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). University of Windsor, Windsor.
Smith, B., & Caddick, N. (2012). Qualitative methods in sport: A concise overview for guiding social scientific sport research. Asia Pacific Journal of Sport and Social Science, 1, 60- 73. doi:10.1080/21640599.2012.701373
Smith, K. L., & Weir, P. L. (2018, October). Advantage reversals and relative age: Does positive youth development play a role? Journal of Exercise, Movement, and Sport, 50, 186. Retrieved from: https://www.scapps.org/jems/index.php/1/article/view/1892
Smith, K. L., & Weir, P. L. (2013). An examination of the relative age effect in developmental girls’ hockey in Ontario. High Ability Studies, 24(2), 171-184. doi: 10.1080/13598139.2013.847357
Smith, K. L., Weir, P. L., Till, K., Romann, M., & Cobley, S., (2018). Relative age effects within female sport contexts: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Sports Medicine, 48(6), 1451-1478. doi: 10.1007/s40279-018-0890-8
Sparkes, A. C., & Smith, B. (2014). Qualitative research methods in sport, exercise and health: From process to product. New York: Routledge.
Sparkes, A. C., & Smith, B. (2009). Judging the quality of qualitative inquiry: Criteriology and relativism in action. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 10, 491–497.
Stenling, A., & Holmström, S. (2014). Evidence of relative age effects in Swedish women’s ice hockey. Talent Development & Excellence, 6(1), 31-40.
Sullivan, P. J., LaForge-MacKenzie, K., & Marini, M. (2015). Confirmatory factor analysis of the youth experiences survey for sport (YES-S). Open Journal of Statistics, 5, 421-429.
Temi. (2019). Speech to text transcription. Retrieved from https://www.temi.com/
Wattie, N., Schorer, J., & Baker, J. (2015). The relative age effect in sport: A developmental systems model. Sports Medicine, 45(1), 83-94. doi: 10.1007/s40279-014-0248-9
Wattie, N., Sornberger, B., & Fraser-Thomas, J. (2018). The influence of relative age on youths’ developmental experiences in sport. Journal of Exercise, Movement, and Sport, 50, 200. Retrieved from: https://www.scapps.org/jems/index.php/1/article/view/1906
Webdale, K., Baker, J., Schorer, J., & Wattie, N. (2019). Solving sport’s ‘relative age’ problem: A systematic review of proposed solutions. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology. doi: 10.1080/1750984X.2019.1675083
Weir, P. L., Smith, K. L., Paterson, C., & Horton, S. (2010). Canadian women’s ice hockey - evidence of a relative age effect. Talent Development & Excellence, 2(2), 209-217.
Weiss, M. R., & Fretwell, S. D. (2005). The parent-coach/child-athlete relationship in youth sport: Cordial, contentious or conundrum? Research Quarterly for Exercise and Sport, 76(3), 286-305. doi: 10.1080/02701367.2005.10599300